Top 10 Best Crib Mattress Reviews
Rating:5 out of5 with 3 ratings
HomeBaby GearTop 10 Best Crib Mattress Reviews

Top 10 Best Crib Mattress Reviews

calendarMay 15, 2017

So your wife is pregnant and in a few days, a new member of your family will be born. If you have haven't already, now's the perfect time to buy things like the furniture and supplies which your baby will need. One of the first things you should invest in is a good mattress for your baby's crib. Read on to find out which is the best crib mattress available.

10 Best Crib Mattresses in 2017
(click links to see Amazon Reviews)
6 of 10
20.00 lbs
6.00 inches
Free shiping
Thick springs, rigid support at sides from border bars, high-quality pad, made in the USA
Premium price, loud springs
Bottom line:
This mattress from the family-owned brand, Colgate justifies its moderately high price with its use of quality materials. It'll also last you longer than other mattresses as it can be flipped over and used when your baby grows into a toddler.
9 of 10
10.30 lbs
5.00 inches
Free shiping
Light and easy to handle with one hand, mattress doesn't sag or get compressed over time, waterproof
Slightly firm mattress
Bottom line:
As numerous positive reviews can attest, this mattress for cribs by Moonlight Slumber is reliable and remains just as good as new over months of use. Being waterproof can be very convenient and makes this the best organic crib mattress that's available.
10 of 10
1.20 lbs
10.00 inches
Free shiping
Fits on standard size mattress like a glove, machine washable, long warranty period
The thin mattress pad won't cushion the firmness of the mattress you're putting it on by much
Bottom line:
This mattress cover from PUREgrace with a TENCEL construction is an easy and comparatively cheap way to improve any mattress that you already have or are planning to buy. It's super soft and waterproof.
7 of 10
7.80 lbs
5.50 inches
Free shiping
Very durable, affordable price tag
Poor after sales support, chemical smell, may be too small
Bottom line:
It Poor after sales support, chemical smell, may be too small.
6 of 10
7.00 lbs
5.00 inches
Free shiping
Long warranty period, excellent customer support and after-sales service from Graco, affordable yet feature-packed and high-quality
Too soft and provides less support to an infant's body, might have trouble expanding to full size
Bottom line:
Graco is a reputable company and the fact that they're selling a mattress at this cheap of a price means that you can blindly go for it. It has all the features and safety precautions you need and comes in compact packaging.
8 of 10
10.40 lbs
5.50 inches
Free shiping
Suitable for toddlers and infants, good value proposition, compact packaging
Cover is easy to tear, zipper can be broken
Bottom line:
With so many options out there, it can be hard to choose a cheap crib mattress that is actually good. Thankfully this one made by Milliard delivers on all fronts and is something you can rely on to provide your child quality sleep.
7 of 10
11.30 lbs
5.00 inches
Free shiping
Comfortable, safe, tight fit in cribs
A little bit expensive, smell can take days to go away
Bottom line:
This premium memory foam mattress is great for those who don't mind spending a little extra to get a product that stays true to its word. My First Mattress have made a mattress that is reliable, comfortable and safe.
8 of 10
8.30 lbs
5.00 inches
Free shiping
Durable, lightweight and easy to change sheets on, stain-resistant
Might be a bit too firm for some children, friction on the cover produces squeaky noises
Bottom line:
This mattress from Sealy is one of the only such to use soybean in its foam core. This unique choice of material is what gives this mattress an edge over others and makes it better. Its firmness makes it the best newborn crib mattress.
9 of 10
16.00 lbs
16.00 inches
Free shiping
Square corners to fit tightly in crib, can be used for toddlers as well as infants as it's double sided
A bit firm, not completely waterproof
Bottom line:
Serta's mattress presents some unique and appealing differences and deviations from the status quo that will interest you if you are looking for a baby mattress with enhancements to make it better.
6 of 10
25.40 lbs
6.00 inches
Free shiping
Made in USA quality, lifetime warranty, double sided
Heavy, depresses a little over time with use
Bottom line:
This matress made in America by Simmons Kids is one of the few spring mattresses to be featured on this list. It provides comfort and security but it's on the heavier side as it has many metal springs inside.

1. Colgate 2N1 Innerspring Toddler and Crib Mattress with Waterproof Cover, White

Colgate 2N1 Innerspring Toddler and Crib Mattress with Waterproof Cover, WhitePrice: $164.99 from


  • Made in the USA
  • Fits all standard American cribs
  • There is a spring unit with more steel and border rods for extra firmness
  • Non-allergic and natural cotton
  • One side is firm, another one is cushioned.
  • High-quality spring unit.
  • It is waterproof.
  • Rather expensive item.
  • The springs are solid, but loud.

Colgate is a company which specializes in crib mattresses and has over 50 years of experience manufacturing them. This particular one, the 2N1 Innerspring Toddler and Crib Mattress, is a comfortable and safe mattress which is manufactured in the USA. The "2N1" (two in one) in the name comes from the fact that the two sides of the mattress have different levels of stiffness. The firmer side provides more support which infants need, while the other side is more cushioned, as toddlers prefer. The foam used in the mattress has been certified by CertiPUR-US and other reputed organizations as being completely safe. It's high-quality and won't trigger any allergies that your child may have.

This quality mattress made by Colgate is designed to fit snugly into cribs and toddler beds of the standard American size.

The GreenGuard Gold certification ensures that this mattress made by Colgate has no harmful emissions. Its cushioning consists of natural cotton. The insulator pad consists of coir fiber made from the husk of coconut shells. The spring unit is high-quality too and has 12.5 gauge springs. The edge of the mattress is reinforced with a steel rim and border rods to provide more support at the edges. The mattress cover is well-made as well and presents several advantages from a usability standpoint. Not only is it waterproof, but it's tear resistant as well. It does this by using a triple-layered and reinforced design in its construction. The seams are strong too.

2. Little Dreamer Crib Mattress with Dual Firmness (FFP) by Moonlight Slumber

Little Dreamer Crib Mattress with Dual Firmness (FFP) by Moonlight SlumberPrice: $196.90 from


  • It is waterproof and hypoallergenic
  • It may be easily cleaned with a damp sponge
  • It does not get compressed over the time
  • Easy to handle.
  • Lightweight.
  • The sleeping surface is very comfortable and PVC and Vinyl Free.
  • High material quality.
  • The mattress is not solid enough.

The Little Dreamer mattress is another great option that you should consider for your baby's crib. It's built in the USA by Moonlight Slumber, a reputed brand of baby products. This crib mattress has all the features and securities you would expect from a top-notch premium mattress. Moonlight Slumber knows that people can't comprise when it comes to their children and this philosophy shows in their product, so the safety of children is our number one concern.

The mattress has an internal fire barrier made from natural fibers. The cover is made from medical grade nylon fabric that's non-toxic. The Gold Certification from GreenGuard that the product is completely free from any emissions. It lacks substances which could cause harmful reactions and allergies such as vinyl, polyethylene and phthalates. It's free from PVC and lead as well.

As the name suggests, it is a dual firmness mattress. That means that one side is made from firmer foam to support an infant while the other side is padded with relatively softer foam to be more comfortable for toddlers. This increases the lifespan of the product as you can simply flip it over when your child grows older. Moonlight slumber didn't compromise with the mattress cover either. It is strongly stitched at the seams and is waterproof. It's hypoallergic too. Cleaning it is as easy as wiping it with a damp cloth.It's treated with antimicrobial protection too.

3. PUREgrace 28 by 52 Inch Waterproof Hypoallergenic Soft Tencel Protector for Crib Mattress

PUREgrace 28 by 52 Inch Waterproof Hypoallergenic Soft Tencel Protector for Crib Mattress

Price: $39.99 from


  • The item is provided in two sizes
  • A smooth and luxurious sleeping surface
  • The mattress cover fits all standard toddler mattresses.
  • One of the most luxurious mattresses on the market
  • There is 10 YEAR Warranty.
  • The protector is machine-washable.
  • A mattress protector consists of a 100% TENCEL cover.
  • It is BPA, VINYL, PVC & PHTHALATES free.
  • There are no plastic smells or toxic emissions.
  • The thin mattress pad.

This product is a mattress protector made by PUREgrace. It's made from organic materials. The cover is fashioned out of 100% pure TENCEL. TENCEL is a pure and botanic fiber derived from the eucalyptus tree. The TENCEL used for this mattress is produced from trees which were grown in eco-friendly conditions without the use of pesticides and herbicides. It is softer than silk and cooler than linen. It is excellent at managing moisture as well. It quickly absorbs moisture and releases it, keeping your baby's environment dry. This also prevents bacterial growth and bed bugs without the use of additional chemicals.

This is the best waterproof crib mattress cover. The waterproofing layer is sandwiched between the bottom two layers of the cover, ensuring that isn't damaged when washing or drying in a dryer. The waterproof material doesn't make use of vinyl, PVC, BPA or phthalates. It gives off no plastic smells or toxic emissions.

The 10-year warranty that PUREgrace ships this cover for baby mattresses guarantees that you're buying a quality product and gives peace of mind.

In addition, this mattress cover is also machine washable. It's got a sleek design and is easy to take on or off a mattress. It fits on snugly and securely. The corners are deep-pocketed and reinforced for added safety. Elastic straps connect the sides and secure the cover firmly to the mattress. There's some padding in the top of the mattress cover as well which make it feel more luxurious to sleep, without adding any extra bulk.

4. Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Colored Mattress For Cribs

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Colored Mattress For Cribs from Safety 1st

Price: $59.30 from


  • It is provided in three colors: light blue, light pink and white
  • Vinyl cover is waterproof
  • Lightweight and durable
  • This item has achieved GREENGUARD GOLD Certification
  • It is phthalates and lead free.
  • The thermo bonded core provides firm support.
  • The vinyl sleeping surface is hypoallergenic.
  • During the first usage there may be a chemical smell.

The Heavenly Dreams matress manufactured by the company Safety 1st is a great, cheap crib mattress. This mattress has several features and presents several benefits despite its affordable price tag. This number 1 bestselling crib mattress on Amazon has a high-density thermo-bonded core of foam. It is firm and provides good support. It is lightweight and easy to handle with one hand. This useful when you're trying to change the sheets, for example. The product has low chemical or toxic gas emissions as well. The cover of the Heavenly Dreams Mattress is waterproof. It does this by being made of vinyl.

Some people do face a bit of a chemical smell when first using this due to this reason. However, it the smell dissipates after a few days of use. The sleeping surface is hypoallergenic, preventing allergens from sticking onto the mattress and harming your child. It's free from phthalates, BPA and lead too. It's definitely earned its GreenGuard Gold Certification.

The mattress meets the federal flammability standard of 16 CFR 1633. What's more is that it accomplishes this without the use of harmful added chemicals that could be detrimental to a child's health and growth. The mattress comes in three different color options. You can buy it in the standard white or something more colorful like the other two choices which are light blue and pink.

5. Graco Toddler And Crib Bed Mattress made from Premium Foam

Graco Toddler And Crib Bed Mattress made from Premium Foam, Full and Standard Sized

Price: $34.00 from


  • It comes compressed in a box
  • The box with a mattress is light and portable
  • It is water – resistant
  • 6 year Warranty
  • It meets federal flammability standards.
  • Safe and cozy.
  • It is anti-static and anti-microbia.
  • The mattress cover is removable and washable.
  • Phthalates and Lead free.
  • There may be some troubles during the mattress expanding.
  • It is extremely soft.

Graco is a well known and respected brand of baby products. This mattress made by them only furthers the brand's reputation. The mattress is unique in the way you receive it. It comes compressed in a box. Once you take it out, you can unroll it to lie flat on a surface. Then the magic happens. The mattress inflates right in front of you and takes its full shape and dimensions. Graco says that it can take up to 72 hours or 3 days for the mattress to size up completely.

The advantage of this approach is that the box they ship the mattress is small, lightweight and portable. This reduces the overall cost and lets you get a quality product for less money. Putting on a tight cover can cause this mattress to shrink a bit. You can then use this as the best mini crib mattress.

You won't have to compromise on brand, build quality or features with this one. It's got all the modern features that any good baby mattress worth its mettle has got. For example, it's waterproof. There's an inner lining which prevents moisture from entering. The mattress will keep your baby clean and dry as Graco claim.

It's also anti-static and anti-microbial. The mattress accomplishes this without the use of potentially harmful substances like phthalates and lead. The mattress meets federal flammability standards as well. All these features mean that you can rest assured that your baby is sleeping in the safest environment possible if you decide to use this mattress. The mattress has a separate cover which is removable and can be washed easily. You can be assured of Graco's quality as they provide a 6-year limited warranty with this mattress.

6. Milliard Toddler Bed Mattress or Baby Crib Mattress With Hypoallergenic and Waterproof Encasement

Milliard Toddler Bed Mattress or Baby Crib Mattress With Hypoallergenic and Waterproof Encasement

Price: $51.00 from


  • It has a superior high density construction
  • It is pretty soft
  • The unique blend of foam ensures the safety and comfort
  • It is compressed in a small box
  • The reasonable price.
  • The item is free from any chemical substances.
  • It is encased in a hypoallergenic waterproof cover.
  • The zipper can be easily broken.

Milliard's mattress for crib and toddler beds is another great option for those looking for the best crib mattress on a budget. Milliard used premium foam in the core of this mattress. It's softer than other baby crib mattresses which are typically firm. At the same time, however, it doesn't compromise on providing support to your infant. This mattress is both safe and comfortable. Your baby won't have any trouble sleeping on this one.

The unique blend of foam is of certified CertiPUR-US quality and provides a perfect balance of comfort and firmness.

The mattress cover has a trendy polka dot pattern which sets this mattress apart from other generic looking white ones in the looks department. It's waterproof but only on the top and the sides of the mattress. The bottom of the mattress meanwhile allows air to ventilate and heat to flow to and from the mattress. The mattress fits snugly into all American cribs for babies which are standardly sized.

It comes vacuum sealed and compressed in a small box. On arrival, you open it and let it decompress. The process can take up to 48 hours. Milliard is aware than the foam mattress may have a chemical smell on arrival. They promise that it'll go away after use in open air. There's nothing to worry about as the mattress is free from any and all harmful chemicals.

7. My First Baby Mattress for Cribs with Premium Memory Foam Construction and Removable Waterproof Cover

My First Baby Mattress for Cribs with Premium Memory Foam Construction and Removable Waterproof CoverPrice: $91.49 from


  • A Mattress is waterproof and washable
  • The item meets CPSC standards
  • It is available with either a plain cover or a quilted one
  • It is firm, but very comfortable.
  • There are no any chemical substances.
  • The cover is removable and hypoallergenic.
  • It fits on all cribs.
  • The price is not reasonable.
  • There may be smell during the first days of usage.

This mattress from My First Mattress is one the best crib mattresses. It's adherence to the principles of quality and safety allows this one to stand apart in a crowded market. It's got all sorts of precautions and safety measures which add up to provide a secure and protected environment for your child to rest in. Let's start with the foam that constitutes the bulk of the inner part of the mattress. It's premium memory foam that's been certified by CertiPUR-US. It's flexible and made from polyurethane.

The mattress is firm yet comfortable. It is designed to reduce the risk of the suffocation and SIDS. It is extra firm and prioritizes safety above all. The mattress is also free from several toxic substances. Lead, phthalates and formaldehyde are all absent from this mattress. Mercury, lead and other heavy metals aren't present either. My First Mattress strictly adhered to the standards set by the Consumer Products Safety Commission (CPSC) when manufacturing this mattress.

The mattress is available with either a plain cover or a quilted one, with the latter being more expensive. Both function well and serve their purpose. The cover is waterproof regardless of the version you get and removable as well. It's hypoallergenic too.

8. Sealy Crib Mattress with Soybean Foam-Core

Sealy Crib Mattress with Soybean Foam-CorePrice: $104.85 from


  • Extra firm lightweight foam crib mattress
  • It is designed for infants and toddlers approximately 0-4 years
  • The model patterns can vary
  • Square corner design
  • The cover is waterproof and it is easy to clean.
  • There is a lifetime warranty on workmanship and materials.
  • It fits all USA standard size cribs and toddler beds.
  • It is practical for sheet changes.
  • It may be extremely firm for some kids.
  • The cover produces strange noise.

Sealy is a trusted company in the field of making mattresses for babies. It's been voted as America's Best Brand for Baby. Their cribs, pads and mattresses have earned them several Women's Choice Awards over the years. This particular mattress made by Sealy in America, with a soybean-derived foam core, is also an award-winning mattress. It's extra firm and lightweight and made from soybean oils that come from American farms. It's been certified by GreenGuard as being appropriate for children and schools. It's no secret that indoor air quality and low chemical emissions are better for children trying to sleep.

The material of the foam is based on soy and designed to be firm and provide support. This reduces the sagging or forming or indents where your baby sleeps on the mattress. It retains its shape and stays just like new. The added durability is another advantage of the soy based construction. The foam material is CertiPUR-US Certified high-density foam. It has a layer of cotton cushioning above it in the mattress. This makes the mattress firm yet comfortable at the same time.

The cover is water-resistant and easy to clean. Just wipe away anything on the cover with wet cloth. It has a pearl embossed pattern is nice to look at and feel. It won't allow allergens to stick to the mattress cover. The cover's binding is also waterproof. Liquids and stains won't be able to seep into the mattress as a result.

9. Serta Supreme Perfect Start Mattress for Cribs and Toddler Beds

Serta Supreme Perfect Start Mattress for Cribs and Toddler BedsPrice: $119.99 from


  • It features a firm thermobonded polyester fiber core
  • There is a waterproof cover
  • It meets the strictest GREENGUARD standards
  • There is a Cool Twist Gel Memory foam for enhanced cushioning
  • Extremely lightweight.
  • There is a low toxicity.
  • High-quality materials.
  • A warranty period of 35 years.
  • The item is not completely waterproof.

Serta has spent plenty of time to researching and developing a mattress that presents a genuine innovation in the field. It uses Cool Twist Gel Memory foam for enhanced cushioning. The foam is exclusive to Serta and uses liquid gel to improve the airflow in the mattress. This regulates the temperature of the mattress effectively to provide the maximum comfort to your child.

The core is made from high-density thermo-bonded polyester fiber. This allows the mattress to be extra firm and lightweight at the same time. Its lightness means you won't have a tough time changing the sheets on this one. The firmness ensures that your baby faces no threat of suffocation while sleeping in this mattress. The probability of facing SIDS is next to nil.

The cover of the mattress is made of organically blended cotton which is woven with a medical grade waterproof backing. It also has a friendly looking but understated pattern of cows on it.

Of course, being a premium mattress, the unit has all the necessary certification that proves the products safety and low toxicity. It has a GreenGuard Gold Certification. It meets the strictest of standards set by the GreenGuard Environmental Institute. The foam used is certified by CertiPUR-US. The product is made by Serta in the USA. This is excellent from a safety standpoint because you can be assured that you're getting a high-quality product that has stood through rigorous quality checks and used genuine materials for its construction. In addition, Serta also provides a long warranty period of 35 years with the product to guarantee customer satisfaction.

10. Simmons Kids Beginnings Beautyrest Ultra Deluxe Sleepy Whispers 2n1 Toddler and Crib Mattress, Neutral

Simmons Kids Beginnings Beautyrest Ultra Deluxe Sleepy Whispers 2n1 Toddler and Crib Mattress, Neutral

Price: $137.15 from


  • 231 luxury Pocketed Coil Springs for even support
  • It has a natural cotton fire protection wrap
  • The item meets all federal flammability standards
  • It is made in the USA
  • It provides a perfect balance of support and comfort.
  • The cover is fire-resistant.
  • The mattress is double sided.
  • It is completely non-toxic.
  • A lifetime warranty.
  • It is rather heavy.

The Beautyrest mattress from Simmons Kids is another high-quality mattress that's produced in the USA. It has 231 luxury Beautyrest Pocketed Spring Coils to provide a perfect balance of support and comfort. The borders are reinforced with protection. There are Innofoam corner protectors as well to provide stability as well. The cover is made from natural cotton fibers and is fire resistant. It contains to harmful chemicals and is completely non-toxic. The GreenGuard Gold Certification backs these claims and the fact that the mattress is made from CertipUR-US certified foam means you should have nothing to worry about.

The cover is woven and has a medical grade waterproof barrier. It is stain resistant and hypoallergenic too. The mattress is double sided. One side is firmer and provides more support to infants for safety reasons. There's no threat of suffocation or SIDS. The other side is more padded. It's softer to make it easier for toddlers to sleep on. It's worth mentioning that this mattress ships with a lifetime warranty too. Simmons Kids are aware of how important it is to choose the right mattress for your baby with is safe and reliable. This warranty should allay any apprehensions you may have and give you peace of mind that you are buying a quality product.

Find some tips to choose the best crib mattress in this video:

  • 3 votes average 5 out of 5
  • iconBy Susy Richards
  • icon1129
  • comments0
Leave a Reply
You May Also Like...